SOCIAL HEALTH OF ABORIGINAL PREGNANCY IN VICTORIA

A Major Research Project by Angelina Tabuteau Moore on behalf of Elizabeth Hoffman House (2009)

About the project

The development of this research project has been achieved through the consultations undertaken from October 2007 to November 2008 with Aboriginal workers and workers who work with Aboriginal families across Victoria using the Questions for Consultation. A final report was submitted to VACCHO in March 2009 and endorsement for continuing to pilot a survey was granted in August 2009.

As from June 2009, the Elizabeth Hoffman House Aboriginal Womens Services Incorporated has agreed to auspice the project and this arrangement will be in place through to completion (anticipated December 2011). This ensures that information obtained through this research will be retained by the Aboriginal community and will contribute to promoting awareness of Aboriginal women’s issues.

It is envisaged that this research will provide an accurate description about the social health characteristics of Aboriginal women in Victoria during pregnancy and post birth and will provide an enriched understanding of their use of services. The research findings could be used to enhance existing service delivery and cross coordination, between Aboriginal and non Aboriginal services, and to provide Aboriginal workers and workers who work with Aboriginal communities, accurate data that can be used to advocate for change and to assist in the development of new programs or services.

(Back to top)

Study Protocol

Aims

To investigate the social health characteristics of Aboriginal women and women with an Aboriginal partner during pregnancy and post birth. To investigate the use of services by Aboriginal women and women with an Aboriginal partner during pregnancy and post birth. To determine the factors that may contribute to women’s perception of positive and negative outcomes during pregnancy and post birth.

Inclusion criteria

All Aboriginal women (and women with an Aboriginal partner) who have a baby in Victoria during January to December 2009 will be invited to participate. As this initial project is a pilot, women from selected communities will be invited to participate.

Exclusion criteria

Women who have had a stillbirth or whose baby is not living. A pregnancy that resulted from trauma.

(Back to top)

Study size

An estimate of 200 women will be invited to participate from communities with a mix of service options.

Promotion of the project

A range of approaches to inform and invite women to participate will be used. These approaches include:

  • Develop an extensive promotional strategy that is focused on raising local knowledge and understanding about the study
  • Develop a plain language brochure and other promotional materials (eg. Postcard, magnets, posters) including information about why the research is being undertaken
  • Distributing information about the project through relevant community services and programs including Aboriginal Hospital Liaison Officers, Koori Maternity Services, Best Start, Playgroups, Maternal and Child Health and others such as women’s groups.
  • Regular promotion of the project in the Koori Mail, Koori radio and newsletters
  • Engage with Maternal and Child Heath Services to assist in promoting and recruiting women to participate
  • Development of a project website and branding (for example, logo design)
  • Establishment of local networks to support promotion and participation from eligible women in the study

These approaches are consistent with the feedback suggested by workers during the consultations. Workers agreed with the approach of recruiting women and promoting the research through Maternal and Child Health Nurses based within Aboriginal and non Aboriginal services. Many workers felt that promoting the research through existing antenatal classes and potentially at places where women have to wait around for a while, such as centrelink, courthouse, hospital will also increase participation of women. Hosting local bbq’s or other community events will also increase awareness of the project and may be an ideal opportunity to recruit women.

(Back to top)

Local Network Groups and Local Project Agreements

The consultations have been coordinated by local workers, usually by a key contact person who then promote and invite others to attend. These informal local networks have been extremely valuable and useful to not only thinking about the design of the study but more importantly, the study’s implementation into community and dissemination of results. It is important for these informal local network groups to continue to be supported to meet, to review and discuss parts of the project that will have the greatest impact on workers and to find ways to minimize disruption and intrusion of community life.

Local project agreements are agreements for conducting research within that specific Aboriginal community. It is proposed that the project agreement will detail the research aims and conduct of the study, for example, the local agreement could provide clear pathways for responding to women who have become/or become distressed during the course of the interview (for example). The interview/project officer could refer to the project agreement which provides clear direction about referrals, roles and responsibilities. The intention of the local project agreements is to minimize worker disruption and confusion.

(Back to top)

Conduct of Interviews

Women (who meet the eligibility criteria) who would like to take part will be asked to participate in a one on one interview. Other options are being explored, including a written or an online version of the survey. Interviews would be undertaken by a small team of trained (Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal) interviewers.

Women participating in the research will be given written and verbal (oral) information about the research and all participants will be provided with a resource guide (to be developed through the local network groups) of useful telephone numbers of local or regional services and programs of potential interest. Participants will be asked to sign a consent form or to give verbal (oral) consent prior to participating in an interview in the form a written protocol (agreement) which will cover:

  • Information to be given to women prior to seeking written or verbal consent to participate
  • Confidentiality procedures and data security
  • Procedures for responding to questions and/or any requests for advice or assistance from women taking part
  • Procedures for responding appropriately if a woman taking part becomes upset or distressed at any stage during an interview
  • Avenues for providing support and referral for women seeking assistance
  • Avenues for interviewers to seek support and confidential advice from senior members of the research team/local networks about any issues that they are concerned about.

Interviews will be conducted in a range of settings including community controlled services and women’s homes. It will be up to women to decide where and when they would like the interview to take place.

All women taking part in an interview will be offered reimbursement for their time and story.

(Back to top)

Survey design and overview

There is strong support for the development of a questionnaire booklet to be used as the basis for conducting interviews. One advantage of this method is that it enables women to see that all women are being asked the same questions, and to see the way that their answers are recorded. The major themes for the data items in the questionnaire include:

  • Social health issues
  • Services used during pregnancy
  • Services used post pregnancy
  • About the pregnancy

1) Social health issues

This list of social, psychosocial and life events were identified during the community consultations as a growing concern for workers.

    SOCIAL

  • Mother and father age
  • Relationship status
  • Living arrangements/housing
  • Urban/Rural
  • Income
  • Employmenty
  • Education
  • Number of children
    PSYCHOSOCIAL

  • Drug Use
  • Depression / Grief and Loss / Mental Health
  • Stress
  • Smoking
  • Alcohol
  • Child Sex Abuse
  • Child Protection Involvement
  • Family Violence
  • Justice Issues
  • Social / Family Support
    LIFE EVENTS

  • Removal from family / community
  • Deaths
  • Illness
  • Loss of job
  • Moving House
  • Separation
  • Loss of partner
  • Disability
  • Violence

2) Services used during pregnancy

Services include Aboriginal and non Aboriginal primary health care, acute health care and other Aboriginal and non Aboriginal services accessed during pregnancy, such as family violence, financial assistance, legal support, drug and alcohol, housing, charitable services etc. It is envisaged that questions will be asked about participants experience of accessing these services, for example Where there limitations to accessing those services? How did you get to those services?

3) Services used after pregnancy

Services include Aboriginal and non Aboriginal primary health care, acute health care and other Aboriginal and non Aboriginal services accessed post pregnancy, such as family violence, financial assistance, legal support, drug and alcohol, housing, charitable services etc. It is envisaged that questions will be asked about participants experience of accessing these services, for example: Where there limitations to accessing those services? How did you get to those services?

4) About the pregnancy

  • Number of pregnancy visits including first presentation
  • Where visits took place (health service, hospital, at home)
  • Pregnancy caregivers (health worker, midwife, doctor, other workers)
  • Length of hospital stay
  • Method of birth
  • General health during and post pregnancy/birth
  • Breastfeeding or bottlefeeding

(Back to top)

Dissemination of results

A summary report will be produced and made available to all participants involved in its development and data collection. Public presentations by the Project officer will also occur for those existing services consulted during the development of this research project, such as Koori Maternity Services, Best Start, ICAP, Maternal and Child Health and as appropriate, other avenues such as newsletters and website. Regional reports will also be developed and presented through the local network groups. Through the consultations, many communities are keen to know how their own local community compares to other parts of the state or to other similar areas.

(Back to top)

About the Project Officer

Angelina Tabuteau Moore is an Aboriginal woman from Wamba Wamba (Victoria and New South Wales). She was the Aboriginal Hospital Liaison Officer at the Mercy Hospital for Women prior to enrolling (May 2007) in the Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) course full time at the Centre for Molecular, Environmental, Genetic and Analytic Epidemiology, The University of Melbourne.

She commenced in August 2007 at the Murdoch Childrens Research Institute (as the Project Officer for the community consultations) and resigned her Project Officer position from the Murdoch Childrens Research Institute in March 2009 following the successful completion of the community consultations.

From August 2007 – March 2009, her Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) supervisory panel consisted of:

  • Dr Kevin Rowely - Onemda (Principle Supervisor)
  • Dr Catherine Bennett - MEGA (Supervisor)
  • Professor Sandra Eades - Baker Institute IDI Heart & Diabetes (Supervisor)
  • Professor Dr Nick Crofts - The Nossal Institute for Global Health (Supervisor)

A community project steering committee will also be established by Elizabeth Hoffman House Aboriginal Womens Services Incorporated to ensure key milestones are met and to support implementation.

(Back to top)

Contact Information

Angelina Tabuteau Moore
Project Officer and Phd Scholar
0400 104 893

Centre for Molecular, Environmental, Genetic and Analytic Epidemiology
The University of Melbourne.
Level 1 723 Swanston Street
CARLTON VICTORIA 3010

Questions for Consultation

* Is there support for Aboriginal families project?

* What issues/topics should be covered in the study?

* What issues/topics should not be covered in the study?

* What information would be most valuable to Aboriginal communities and community organisations in advocating for better services for Aboriginal women and families?

* Who should be invited to take part in the study?

  • Aboriginal women who have recently had a baby
  • Non Aboriginal women with an Aboriginal partner who have recently had a baby
  • Aboriginal men whose partner has recently had a baby
  • Aunties, Grandmothers?

* Is it appropriate to invite young women (under18) to take part in the study? What age would be too young?

* What are the best ways to inform Aboriginal women and families about the study and invite them to take part?

  • via Aboriginal health services?
  • via forming research partnerships?
  • via community and family (kinship) networks?
  • via Aboriginal hospital liaison officers?
  • via community newsletters?
  • other methods?

* How should information be collected?

  • individual face-to-face semi-structured interviews
  • individual face-to-face fully structured interviews
  • paper-based self completion questionnaires
  • telephone interviews
  • on-line self-completion questionnaire
  • group-based interviews (focus groups)
  • other methods?

* What choices should participants be given in relation to who conducts the interview?

  • female/male interviewers
  • Aboriginal/non-Aboriginal interviewers
  • interpreter and/or interviewer who speaks their first language
  • local/non-local interviewers?

* What choices should participants be given in relation to where interviews are conducted?

  • in their home
  • at health service
  • somewhere else?

* Is it appropriate for other people to be present?

  • a health worker?
  • partners?
  • other family members?

* Is it OK for oral tape-recordings to be made and transcribed (with participants’ consent)?

* What steps in addition to standard procedures should be taken to ensure that all individual information remains confidential?

Standard procedures

* all staff to sign confidentiality agreements
* oral and/or written consent obtained from all participants in research
* during fieldwork staff will be responsible for storage of information collected in the project in locked metal filing cabinets
* information gathered during fieldwork will be transferred as soon as possible to a secure locked storage area at the HMHF group at MCRI
* firewall and password protection of all computer files
* storage of consent forms and any other identifying information in a separate location from interview or questionnaire data
* How are participants reimbursed for their time?
* How should information gathered in the study be reported back to participants, to community organisations and to community members?

  • project newsletters
  • project website
  • community meetings
  • other methods?

* How should information gathered in the study be used:

  • to advocate for improved service delivery
  • to advocate for increased resources for Aboriginal community controlled health services
  • to inform government about the needs of Aboriginal communities
  • other ways?

* What needs to happen/what do the researchers need to do to ensure that there is community control and ownership of information?

(Back to top)